9 min read

8 Crucial Steps for Analyzing a Vacation Rental Investment

Buying property is like playing blackjack. It’s a bit of a gamble, but if you do the math it can be quite profitable.

Traditionally, real estate investing meant you either bought the property for appreciation, to rent it to long-term occupants, or for both reasons. Some also bought property to use it for vacation rental, but it was harder to find guests. Now, purchasing an investment property for short-term vacation rental expands those options—you can easily rent for shorter periods, get a higher cash-on-cash return (CoC) and cap rate, and sell for capital appreciation.

To have a successful short term rental (STR) business, you need to do the due diligence and perform a vacation rental investment analysis. By the end of this blog, you’ll be able to analyze the property you want to buy and compare it against other options in eight simple steps.

Wondering how much money you can make out of your short-term rental?
There’s no need to spend hours analyzing your vacation property investment. Enter the Jetstream and leverage our tools and expertise to get an answer.

Table of contents

Benefits and pitfalls of short-term rental investment

Investing in short-term rental property has several benefits, especially when compared to long-term rentals. Here are three reasons why you should consider investing in a second home for vacation rental.

Higher cash-on-cash (CoC) return

A short-term rental allows you to get a faster return on investment (ROI) and a higher CoC than other types of real estate investments. In fact, Bill Faeth, entrepreneur and real estate investor, says you should never settle for an Airbnb or any other kind of STR property for less than 30% CoC.

It’s almost impossible to get a similar number with long-term rentals, with the usual CoC rate being around 8%.

Better cash flow

Renting your property for short periods and weekend getaways lets you invest for cash flow.

This means you’ll be able to pay off your debt, maximize vacation rental income, and get a passive income at the same time. Also, if you do a proper short-term rental investment analysis and buy a property in a booming market you can also invest for future capital appreciation.

Secure your retirement

The best retirement fund is one that includes diversified investments. Along with placing your money on a retirement fund or becoming a stock owner, entering the real estate market for vacation rentals is a way of ensuring a living wage that may allow your early retirement.

However, investing in STR can easily go sideways if you don’t do the due diligence to understand the market, research the best location and property, run the numbers, and invest time to manage your vacation rental.

When you buy a property to use as an STR, you’re also giving yourself a lot of responsibility. Becoming a vacation homeowner means you need to:

  • Answer guest messages at any time
  • Create content for your listings
  • Promote your property on different online travel agencies (OTAs) and rental platforms
  • Find cleaners, hot tub chemists, gardeners, pool cleaners, and painters
  • Manage your contractors and guests schedules
  • Collect payments and save money in an escrow account for future insurance and taxes payments
  • Screen your guests and get STR insurance to protect your home
  • Adjust your prices according to high demand and peak seasons

That’s why, along with the STR market analysis, you should look into hiring a team of professionals like Jetstream to manage your property remotely.

Wondering how much money you can make out of your short-term rental?
There’s no need to spend hours analyzing your vacation property investment. Enter the Jetstream and leverage our tools and expertise to get an answer.

8 Steps for smart vacation rental investment analysis

Before entering the vacation rental business, you should do a short-term rental investment analysis. Here are eight steps that you need to follow to properly analyze the market and the vacation rental industry.

1. Determine your buying power

The first thing you should do is meet with a certified public accountant (CPA) to get advice on your personal finances. This way you’ll know how much you can pay and how to make the most clever decision. During this meeting, you should be able to determine:

  • The percentage of the downpayment that you need to make based on the purchase price and your savings
  • The time you can afford to pay for the property yourself in case you can’t rent it right away
  • If you can afford closing costs along with other associated expenses
  • If there are any tax benefits to buying this property, how much taxes are left to pay, and insurance costs

01-A-Person-Giving-a-Bundle-of-Keys-to-another-Person-2048x1365

Becoming a homeowner comes with attained liability. A CPA and a lawyer can help you reduce risk levels.

2. Analyze the market

To analyze the market of vacation homes you should go to Zillow, Propersum, Mashvisor, or Vrolio. You should factor in prices, dimensions, and property status when calculating. Also, you should:

  • Check for boots-on-the-ground. It’s important that you know if you have nearby services and contractors available that are willing to work for you. This way you can scale your business and manage remotely
  • Estimate appreciation. It’s not possible to have an accurate estimate of the appreciation value, but you can research what’s happening in the market you’re researching. Maybe they’re opening a new amusement park soon or they’re closing down a big office
  • Check out the competition. It’s important that you take some time to analyze them. You don’t want to invest in a place that’s overcrowded with beautiful listings that are struggling to be booked. But you also don’t want to invest in a market that has zero options. Consider getting advice from expert property investment consultants like Jetstream.

Wondering how much money you can make out of your short-term rental?
There’s no need to spend hours analyzing your vacation property investment. Enter the Jetstream and leverage our tools and expertise to get an answer.

3. Review the local law and regulations

Each state, city, and county has its own regulations. Review the local law to ensure it’s legal to operate an STR in that location. RentResponsibility.org is a great place to look this up. It’s your responsibility to be aware of local laws and regulations, any violations make you liable.

4. Estimate associated expenses

Buying a property comes with associated costs. You should factor those numbers into your budget calculations to evaluate if you can afford to buy the property even if your occupancy rates fall short. Make sure you cater these expenses to the niche you’ll be targeting.

Here are five types of expenses that you should take into consideration:

  • Internet speed. The internet speed will be different if you’re hosting a family staying in your STR and going to Disney than if you’re hosting digital nomads. Define your ideal guest persona and research internet prices in your desired location.
  • Appliances. Based on your persona, define if you need to buy a washer and dryer, an A/C, heating, or a big or a small fridge. Research for prices and models and add the costs to your budget.
  • Smart locks, bulbs, and plugs. If you’re hosting remotely, you need to be able to give your guests access and save power without any hassle. Get quotes on smart devices and include them in your budget.
  • Cost of services. Depending on your property you might need a gardener, pool cleaner, hot tub chemist, or cleaners. Research the costs per hour in your desired location and plan accordingly.
  • Renovations. Define if your desired property is a turn-key operation ready for you to host guests, or if you need to invest in renovations and upgrades. Factor those numbers into your budget.

5. Use tools to estimate ROI, CoC, and cap rate

There are several tools online that can help you estimate ROI, cap rate, and CoC return based on your initial investment and the market stats. Use the information you collected in the previous step and enter it into these tools to get a more accurate income estimation.

Software that can help you calculate your earnings includes:

AirDNA

This tool uses data from Airbnb and Vrbo to help you analyze your short-term rental investment with their MarketMinder app. It offers a month free trial and then costs $50 a month. You only need to enter the address of the property you’re interested in and it will automatically give you estimated values for:

  • Average daily rate
  • Occupancy rate
  • Operating expenses
  • Net operating income
  • Rates per night
  • Seasonality information
  • Rental revenue
  • Cap rate

02-AirDNA-MarketMinder-dashboard-Santa-Monica-analysis

Use AirDNA’s MarketMinder to discover where to invest, set the perfect price, and stay two steps ahead of the competition.
Source: AirDNA

Mashvisor

This tool has a 7-day free trial. Then, it costs $70 per month. Mashvisor is a great software to analyze an Airbnb property or long-term rental investment. Just by entering the property address, you can access these estimates:

  • Cash flow
  • Cash on cash return
  • Cap rate
  • Gross rent multiplier (GRM)
  • Vacancy rates

03-Mashvisor-dashboard-Chicago-analysis

Analyze any neighborhood nationwide in just a few seconds, access powerful analytics, and make a purchasing decision with Mashvisor.
Source: Mashvisor

Vrolio

To use this free tool, you’ll need to have all the information regarding associated costs and expenses. Then, you can enter the information in their investment calculator and get a more accurate estimate for:

  • Average monthly cash flow
  • Annual cash flow
  • Cash on cash return
  • Annual occupancy to break even
  • Break-even occupancy (in weeks)
  • Net operating income (NOI)
  • Cap rate (ROI)

Vrolio-vacation-rental-real-estate-investment-768x434

The Vrolio vacation rental real estate investment calculator allows you to get an accurate estimation of your property annual profits.
Source: Vrolio

6. Consider how quickly you can rent it

If you’re investing in property, you should have extra cash to cover monthly payments while you get guests through your door. Define the length of that waiting period and the expected time for renovations and furnishing. Factor this into your calculations.

7. Get a property investment consultant

While you can make the analysis yourself, you’re better off asking professionals. Jetstream offers consultancy services for property investors that want to make the best possible decision. Book consultation hours with an expert.

8. Buy your STR property

Now that you’ve analyzed your finances, done market research, estimated income and expenses, and reviewed local laws and regulations, you’re ready to purchase your short-term rental property. Sign the papers, make the down payment, and get it ready for your first guest.

How to enter the vacation rental market stress-free

It’s almost impossible to make a stress-free investment. Especially if you’re purchasing a vacation home. Managing an STR can be a lot of work. But if you’re investing for passive income, it makes no sense for you to have active responsibilities. Self-managing your STR is a personal choice that puts you in full control of your property, but also makes you responsible for doing all of the work.

There are two other alternatives to help you manage your vacation rental with less stress:

1. Hire a property manager

Delegate all your responsibilities to a property manager (PM). They can be your boots on the ground and be responsible for:

  • Managing your listings
  • Contacting cleaners, gardeners, and pool cleaners
  • Collecting payments
  • Paying bills

They will most likely charge you a fixed fee upfront and you’ll have little visibility or control over your property. Many PMs will post your listings under their own brands, which means they also own your reviews. This makes it harder to start again if you decide to change companies or self-manage.

2. Outsource a remote management agency like Jetstream

Outsource cleaning management or a realtor to have boots-on-the-ground, but hire an agency like Jetstream to manage all remote responsibilities. Jetstream offers:

  • 24/7 multilingual guest communications
  • Schedule coordination with your contractors
  • Listing and dynamic pricing management and optimization
  • Content creation for listings
  • Direct booking website management
  • Payment collection
  • Timely payment of bills
  • Guest screening

With Jetstream, there are no up-front payments required or hidden fees. You’ll pay a percentage according to your occupancy rate, meaning you won’t pay if you have zero guests. Since we help manage your property remotely, while you keep ownership of all your listings and reviews, it’s easy to scale your business and build your brand.

Is the vacation rental market a good investment?

Investing in STR property means a higher CoC and ROI than with long-term rentals. You’ll have a better cash flow and diversified retirement investments. But it can be a bad move if you don’t understand the market or your finances.

Investments are never one hundred percent predictable. But investing in real estate can be a great way of making a passive income without having to do much of the work yourself—if you outsource the property management.

Hire an agency like Jetstream to manage all the manual work for you, and you’ll never have to answer a guest question, keep your property descriptions up to date, or manually change your prices.

Wondering how much money you can make out of your short-term rental?
There’s no need to spend hours analyzing your vacation property investment. Enter the Jetstream and leverage our tools and expertise to get an answer.

Frequently asked questions about vacation rental investment analysis

How do you calculate the ROI on a vacation rental property?

To calculate the return on investment (ROI) of a vacation rental property you can use tools like AirDNA or Vrolio. You’ll need to have a clear estimate of the price, initial investment, monthly mortgage payments and expenses, price per night, and percentage of occupancy.

What are the pros and cons of vacation rentals?

Owning a vacation rental property has benefits and pitfalls. The pros of buying a vacation rental property are:

  • You get a monthly passive income
  • You invest both for cash flow and asset appreciation
  • It can become part of your retirement plan
  • It has a higher cash flow, CoC, and ROI than long-term rentals

Cons to owning a vacation rental property include:

  • The real estate market isn’t 100% predictable
  • You may need to pay for unexpected expenses
  • It comes with higher taxes and liability than other types of investments

What are some of the hidden costs of a vacation rental?

Some of the often overlooked costs associated with vacation rental properties include:

  • Property taxes
  • Lawyers costs
  • Closing costs
  • Unexpected property upgrades
  • Accidental damage by guests
  • Property management associated costs
  • Homeowners and short-term rental insurance costs
  • HOA payments

What is a good vacancy rate?

A good vacancy rate for short-term rentals varies depending on who you ask. A safe average is a vacancy rate of 33%. However, some property managers consider 50% a good occupancy rate.